Bone-in — Shannon Creek Farm
Goat Shoulder
Shannon Creek Farm, Kansas Flint Hills
Choose your preferred weight from the dropdown menu above.
Goatober is 16 years old! October is the natural season for goat meat, and as we have for over a decade, we are proud to feature cuts of goat as part of our effort to celebrate just how delicious goat meat is.
Anne Saxelby was America’s first all domestic cheesemonger. Her lovely shop connected the New York City public to rural communities and dairies where she learned about a predicament for goat cheese makers — since females are the milk producers there is hardly any need for males. Thus, Anne conceived Goatober and wove a virtuous web of farmers and chefs to make it happen – a seasonal celebration of goat meat from male goats who spent happy lives foraging in the woods! Sixteen years later the project continues thanks to the rolling hilly pastures of Shannon Creek Farm in the Flint Hills of Kansas. Shop goat in its natural season — goats are traditionally born in the Spring and ready for harvest in October! Every nose-to-tail cut is juicy, earthy, clean, nourishing and fulfilling.
Those who experience goat for the first time marvel at how bright, lean, and floral it is. This roast is the perfect hearty addition to winter and spring meals, or is incredible cooked low and slow on the grill. Shoulder meat is a perfect filling for tacos, sandwiches or as a stand alone centerpiece. We recommend covering the roast thoroughly in salt, pepper, olive oil, and rosemary sprigs. Preheat the oven to 400 degrees and then roll it down to 325 to roast the goat, for several hours, until the internal temperature reaches 145 for a perfect medium rare (or a little bit less, as the roast will continue to cook after leaving the oven).
Although leaner than beef or lamb, goat meat is rich and flavorful and boasts light floral notes in every bite. Because goat meat has less fat, it lends itself to slow and low cooking including braises and barbecue — see our Cooking Tab for more information!
Since 2010 Goatober has grown to become a celebration of all things goat, the most widely consumed protein on the planet!
Goat cuts ideal for slow and low cooking like braises and barbecue include leg, shoulder, ribs, and shanks, and goat chops and rack can be seared in a pan.
How to Prepare
1. Take the roast out of the refrigerator an hour prior to cooking.
2. Preheat your oven to 400℉, then roll it down to 325℉ when you put the roast in.
3. Season liberally with salt and pepper on all sides.
4. Sear on all sides in a hot pan until browned.
5. Move to a roasting pan lined with a rack and cook at 325℉ for 30 minutes checking the meat every 15 minutes thereafter until the roast reaches your desired internal temperature (130℉ approximately for goat to medium rare.) The internal temperature will continue to rise slightly after leaving the oven. Let rest for 10-15 minutes before carving.
© 2026, Heritage Foods Powered by Shopify